Posted on 11/29/2012 9:05:26 AM PST by Former Fetus
Yes, or no, Larry. Does the Catholic church teach that Israel has a right to exist and a right to peace?
I’m not playing your game.
My original point that you contested, has been proven and documented.
The Vatican backs a Palestinian state.
Here’s how this works:
You wrote an article that posed this question in the headline:
“Should Christians support the creation of a sovereign Palestinian state?
Joel C. Rosenberg’s Blog ^ | 11/28/2012 | Joel C. Rosenberg “
In Post #16, I responded:
“Nope!
And someday I’d like to hear Rome’s reasoning.
I’ve heard them mouth support, but never a REASON!”
To which you accused me of Catholic bashing.
So, I clarified in post #30:
“I’m a very Conservative Catholic, loyal to the teachings of Rome.
I just don’t happen to understand Rome’s politics, when it comes to Israel.
I keep seeing hints of sympathy for the Pali’s.
Would you care to clarify?”
You disageed in post #37.
So, I suggested:
“Read Vatican writings on the Pali’s.
Never critcal, often supportive.”
And you asked me for evidence, to support that position.
So, when I provide chapter and verse that the Vatican supports a Palestinian state,
You get all defensive, shouting, “ya, but they like Israel too!”, when that has nothing to do with any statement I made, IN DIRECT RESPONSE TO THE QUESTION YOU POSED IN THE HEADLINE!
“I’m not playing your game.”
Answer the question.
Does the Vatican support the right of Israel to exist, and her right to peace from the ROP?
Here is your question:
“Should Christians support the creation of a sovereign Palestinian state?
Joel C. Rosenberg’s Blog ^ | 11/28/2012 | Joel C. Rosenberg “
Here is my answer:
The Vatican supports a Palestinian State, and I don’t know why.
And my PROOF is here:
“New York City, N.Y., Sep 29, 2011 / 01:11 pm (CNA/EWTN News).- Archbishop Dominique Mamberti, the Vatican’s number two State Department official, called Sept. 27 for a two-state solution to the Palestinian-Israeli conflict in remarks delivered in New York. He insisted that “if we want peace, courageous decisions have to be made.”
You lose!
I know why you’re not answering the question, because it also provides the answer to your actual question. And that answer is an answer you do not like. :)
Anyways, answer the question. It’s not a hard question either. The reason the Vatican supports the two state solution is that they believe Israel has the right to exist and that she has the right to defend herself. They believe that the two-state solution establishes Israeli independence for all time. :)
Anyways G Larry, once again.
Does the Vatican support Israel’s right to exist and her right to peace from the ROP? Yes or no?
You picked your sources, not me. The RCC is theologically anti-Zionist. Worst, it must suck up to the Islamists to protect the Christians in Muslim nations from reprisals. Local dhimmi Christians can only survive by proving their Arabsness by hating Jews, as part of the 1400 year Stockholm syndrome of dhimmiya. And then there is leftism and third worldism, which has quite infected the RCC. The RCC looks to the Third World and refuses to even stand up for the heritage of Latin Christendom in its heartland of Europe.They refuse to denouce Eurabia and bend over backwords to applaud the invasion by immigration of Muslims into Europe. Were I a Catholic, I would think the current leadership to be traitors. But i am a Jew and will not get into such things.
“Should Christians support the creation of a sovereign Palestinian state?
Joel C. Rosenberg’s Blog ^ | 11/28/2012 | Joel C. Rosenberg “
Still won’t answer the question. :) Why are you so afraid of answering the question?
I answered the ONLY question on the board.
Your desire to change the subject to avoid having to admit you were WRONG, is not my problem.
“change the subject”
How is it changing the subject when it answers your question? I notice you failed to acknowledge that I answered your question. :)
I guess that wasn’t the answer you wanted, oh well.
But then we all know that you weren’t really looking for an answer. ;)
Why don’t you show us those 2 posts?
1- My question
2- Your answer
The essence of the question I posed in Post #16 was:
“Why does Rome support a Palestinian State?”
And you went on to argue that they don’t.
You ARE WRONG!
Go back and read my posts for once. It’s there. :)
Hint:
There’s nobody else watching 2 guys pee on each other’s shoes.
You lost.
I’m done.
You know what’s more embarrassing than not answering questions - not reading posts. :)
Glad you got outed as a poser.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.