You're dead wrong, and until you accept that you're wrong, and understand why your approach is wrong, you'll just keep spinning your wheels.
Catholics voted democrat as usual, and non-catholic Christians voted hugely republican, in fact they have only voted democrat in 1932, 1936, and 1964.
To a conservative, that is what we want, why do you want people voting democrat?
For the survival of the nation, we have to figure out some way to get Catholics to start voting like the non-catholic Christians.