What you believe the Founders supported is not supported by history, case law, or their own comments and legislation.
And, “Subject to the Jurisdiction thereof” would make anyone with diplomatic immunity not qualified for citizenship.
I don’t agree with your take on history and stand on my take as being founded in recorded facts which are available to anyone. Have to admit that your reference to ‘Subject to the Jurisdiction thereof’ got me to wondering but not enough to give up my belief on eligibility.