[Fantasywriter]

If it’s a tax, then they’re taxing us for being alive. How is that Constitutional?

[Whenifhow]

Art 1, Sec 7 Constitution: 2 raise revenue (taxes) MUST originate in House OCare originated in Senate! Sup Court miss that?

Challenges to Ocare coming!

[KevinB]

If it’s a tax, then they’re taxing us for being alive. How is that Constitutional?

Exactly. They have only said that it's a tax. They have not said that it's a Constitutional tax. And under the Anti-Injunction Act I don't think they can until the tax is assessed against someone and that person challenges it.