This woman is still today required to file as an alien resident. Your premise does not appear to jive with the facts nor does it appear to hold water. Otherwise ICE/INS would be following ex post facto from SCOTUS but in this woman`s case, their MANDATORY documented registration of an resident alien born of an American father and a Mexican mother in Mexico hasn`t changed position in 50 years. She married an American citizen, has 2 children and still has to register every year as a resident alien. I kid you not.
“This woman is still today required to file as an alien resident. Your premise does not appear to jive with the facts nor does it appear to hold water.”
My premise? What do you think my premise is?
My premise is that the Marguet-Pillado dicta claimed by Obama to make him NBC is bogus. You don’t disagree with that, do you?
My research of the Miller case shows that the INS discriminates against the children of US citizen fathers born to foreign mothers. That is not a premis, it is a fact upheld by SCOTUS. The woman you refer to seems to be one of those people. She does not have a US citizen mother who gave birth in a foreign country...as Obama might well have had. So her case is not on-point with Barry’s or with my premise.
The resident alien woman that you refer to...did her US citizen father appear on her BC in Mexico? Was she able to prove her blood relationship to him before she turned 18? Did the US citizen father publicly acknowledge her before she turned age 18?
In part because she did not renounce her Mexican citizenship. That's part of the requirement for those born of US citizen fathers and foreign citizen mothers. Plus there are proof of paternity documents to be filed. After all, who one's mother is is obvious at the time of birth, not so with the father.