Are you just making up a definition of natural born citizen as you go along? Because that's what it seems like.
Maybe you should open a book or 2 that was printed prior to 1900 sometime. Read the actual language of the laws of the time. Especially International Private Law regarding the nationality of a child born in wedlock & that of one born out of wedlock. How about natural law on the subject. John Locke could school you and he isn't that hard to read & understand.
Virginia citizenship law 1779
http://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/a4_2_1s4.html
A treatise on the law of citizenship in the United States: treated historically By Prentiss Webster
http://books.google.com/books?id=ky-TxmjrU0YC&printsec=toc#v=onepage&q=illegitimate&f=false
A treatise on citizenship: by birth and by naturalization, with reference to ... By Alexander Porter Morse
Cyclopedia of law and procedure, Volume 7 By William Mack, Howard Pervear Nash 1903
But it doesn’t stop there. The passport records clearly show he was an Indonesian citizen & either upon his return to the US or upon his coming of age there must have been a formal act, formal paperwork filed renouncing the Indonesian citizenship & the reestablishment of the US citizenship status he held at birth. To date, this has not been established, thus we don't know what country he actually is a citizen of. Perkins v. Elg 1939
NBC if infact it is proven without a shadow of a doubt that he was actually born in one of the 50 US states.