I actually got a new set of four tires for my Explorer, so I guess I ‘won’. Old tires had 60K miles on them, so it was nice.
I was in the same boat with my Ranger. I felt guilty taking the free tires. The only reports of problems with the Wrangler AT tires were in warm climates when people were careless about inflation and drove long distances at high speeds. Idiots, in other words.
I loved my Wrangler AT, btw. My 4FWD Ranger with the Wrangler AT was the absolute best “snow car” I ever had, it could drive through several inches of unplowed snow handily. The replacement tires were never quite as good. I’d buy Wrangler AT if they still made them, any day.