[Huck]

Because to many liberals, the economy is a PIE ... a finite pie

Not only that. They seem to believe everyone stays in one income quintile forever. No one ever starts out earning less, peaks in middle years, then earns less later on. In their minds, they are segregated classes.

[George Smiley]

Because to many liberals, the economy is a PIE ... a finite pie

Look up a George Gilder article entitled "Zero Sum Folly - From Kyoto to Kosovo". He demolishes this fallacy.