Guys don't expect you to keep Valentines gifts, flowers and candy, (except for diamonds of course). If he can afford to give you diamonds for Valentines every year you are lucky indeed.
Its an imaginary holiday designed to extract money from people and make them feel terrible. Women are perpetually disappointed that their partners didn't spend more, and men perpetually feel guilty for not spending enough.
I expect he tossed it out, embarrassed that you would keep it. Bet he never got you a gas station gift again has he?
That was the thing- we never did Valentine’s Day gifts before this. I never expected any gift until he started going on and on about this incredible gift I was going to love.