[fightinJAG]

Yes, you are missing something.

Allen’s birthplace made him an American AT birth, but he was not a citizen BY birth because his father was a British subject.

IOW, Allen was an American citizen, but he was not a natural born citizen and, therefore, was ineligible to be president.

[Badabing Badablonde]

So where is the legal and constitutional discussion of this person’s theory? All I saw was a blogger claiming that someone else’s claims were lies, and then found out he was born in the US anyway, but decided to make a semantics argument out of all of it. And Mavs are ahead by 15 points.

[arrogantsob]

Who is Allen? Arthur was a natural born citizen.

[fso301]

Allen’s birthplace made him an American AT birth, but he was not a citizen BY birth because his father was a British subject.

The article stated Allen's mother was an American citizen.

[Tublecane]

“Allen’s birthplace made him an American AT birth, but he was not a citizen BY birth because his father was a British subject.”

Huh? What point are you trying to make with the prepositions?