Try Farm Bureau. You don’t have to be a farmer to be insured by them. They are very responsive and settle claims really fast. Five years ago when hurricane Isabel went through central Virginia, I didn’t even have to call them. They were at my door the day after the storm hit and spent two hours going over the damage to my property. When they left I had a check in my hand that more than covered the identified repairs, and when I called them about some hidden damage they covered that as well with no problems. They even replaced all of the refrigerated and frozen food we lost due to being without power for ten days. Their rates are very competitive and I have more coverage on my house and autos than with my previous company (Allstate) for the same price. In fact, both Allstate and State Farm came out earlier this year and gave us a quote, and for the same coverage either would have cost me around 18% more a year.
Farm Bureau insurance is the best so is USAA, if you can get it.