_________________________________________________________
"Yes, Neandertals played bagpipes with their noses Posted by Jim Foley on April 01, 2005 | Comments (13) | TrackBack (0)
The April 1997 issue of Discover magazine had a pretty good April Fool's joke about a number of Neandertal musical instruments that had supposedly been discovered in Germany. It was an unlikely collection, featuring bagpipes, a tuba, a triangle and a 'xylobone', along with a cave painting of marching musicians.
In September 2000 the Institute for Creation Research fell for it and featured this evidence in one of their radio programs. I pointed that out on the Fossil Hominids website about a month later, and the ICR quickly apologized and retracted the claim.
However, no erroneous argument ever completely disappears from creationist literature. I've recently noticed the April Fool article cited again in an article by Brad Harrub on the Answers in Genesis website (update: the citation has now been removed).
Harrub also thinks that the Java Man skullcap belongs to a gibbon - even though AIG has admitted that this is a discredited argument that creationists shouldn't use any longer. Harrub's article was also published in AIG's 'peer-reviewed scientific journal', the Technical Journal. What is AIG's peer-review process like, if clangers like these can get through it?
_______________________________________________________
From: http://www.pandasthumb.org/pt-archives/week_2005_03_27.html
Snort.
"What is AIG's peer-review process like, if clangers like these can get through it?"
And what is the evo peer-review process like, if clangers like Prof. Protsch can get through FOR 30 YEARS!!
Specious anecdotal arguments sometimes bite, don't they?
"If it sounds too good to be true, then it probably is. Most of us have heard this piece of advice on more than one occasion. Yet, this was exactly the case with a famous Neanderthal fossil discovered in a peat bog near Hamburg, Germany. Prior to its discovery, the evolutionary timeline of ape-like creatures remained extremely fuzzy as it approached modern man. There simply were not any fossils that shed light on this period. But a single discovery dated by Professor Reiner Protsch cleared up the picture. Many years ago, he was invited to date the famous skull, which he later pronounced to be the vital missing link between Neanderthals and modern humans. He dated the skull at 36,000 years old, allowing it to fall neatly into the evolutionists timeline between Neanderthals and modern man. Finally, thanks to Protsch, the gap had been filled. All the pieces were in place.
For evolutionists, it was too good to be true. And indeed, it was. On February 18, 2005, Protsch was forced to retire in disgrace after a Frankfurt University panel ruled he had fabricated data and plagiarized the work of his colleagues (see Anthropologist Resigns in Dating Disaster, 2005). If this scenario sounds familiar, you are exactly right (see, for example, Piltdown Hoax). Once believed to be a world-renowned expert on carbon dating, Protschs entire professional career is now being questioned. The university noted: The commission finds that Prof. Protsch has forged and manipulated scientific facts over the past 30 years (Anthropologist Resigns
)."