Dear R. Scott,
One can argue the effects of surface tension but the issue has really been settled by the Mariposa Institute Study.
The study used radioactive particles, the size of so called 'HIV', under simulated 'use' conditions.
Around 100 samples of each major condom brand were tested.
Results varied greatly between brands but failure rates as high as 100% were recorded.
The study was commissioned by Durex and so cannot be considered to have an anti condom bias.
I have the results somewhere on file and can post them if you are interested.
Best wishes,
David
ONE FINAL COMMENT
"With a high enough surface tension"
Do you understand the effect of silicone (used as a condom lubricant) on surface tension?
At around 50 centistrokes you could 'kiss surface tension' good bye.
Other condom lubricants have a similar effect.
Results varied greatly between brands but failure rates as high as 100% were recorded.