"...if President Hilary demanded in Spring 2011 that all private guns are to be given up..."
I think a closer analogy would go something like this:
If President Hitlery Clinton and a demoncrat Congress passed legislation that upheld by the Left Court Supremicists that put to death by starvation every conservative in the country at the end of the week the law was passed, the reaction would be "Let's get some new legislation passed... we might be able to get enough votes by the next election... it's the only legal recourse we have! Don't do anything outside of the law!".
Thank GOODNESS our Republic was not born up, upon the shoulders of such weak-kneed men and women of milquetoast fortitude in the face of tyranny and adversity.
We'd have never made it past the first few battles in New England.