Replies

For the twentieth time, I direct your attention to the case of Aldo Mario Bellei. He shares the EXACT same circumstances of birth as does Ted Cruz, and the Supreme court STRIPPED him of his citizenship.

The Court said that not only was it within the Constitutional power of Congress to declare which persons born abroad were citizens at or by birth, it was also within their authority to set a US residency condition for them to maintain their citizenship.

That doesn't say they weren't "natural born citizens" to start with.

Congress also passed a law saying that women born here in the United States to two US citizen parents - what you claim is the very definition of "natural born citizen" could be stripped of their natural born citizenship by marrying a foreigner. And the Supreme Court upheld THAT.

They didn't even have to leave the country, even once, to be stripped of their NATURAL BORN US CITIZENSHIP.

And the Supreme Court upheld the law.

So once again, you're just spinning bullshit.

But you knew that already.

At first I thought I would address your points. Then I remembered that i've done this many times before, and the next time you will simply REPEAT THE SAME CRAP AGAIN.

You aren't interested in clarity, you aren't interested in understanding, you aren't interested in reason, facts, logic, accuracy, history or even good policy.

You are interested in pushing your psychosis on the rest of us, and that is ALL you are interested in.

A naturalized citizen can have his or her citizenship revoked and be deported, BUT a Natural Born Citizen or a born citizen CANNOT, not ever. An anchor baby COULD be compelled to leave with its illegal parents but has absolute right of return after her 18th birthday.

Just exactly WHERE do you deport an NBC TO???

I was starting to think you might have some merit in your arguments when you pulled this one out your Pelosi. How do I know all this? My dealings with immigration to get my LEGAL wife her green card. Now going through it for her son. I am an NBC, btw. Born IN the U. S., of citizen parents whose families go back to the Mayflower.

There is SOME merit to the argument that someone born to a military family on a US base abroad can claim NBC-ship, as there usually are Status of Forces agreements which cover such things. Others born abroad are NOT NBCs, especially if the father is not a citizen, by birth or otherwise. They may be birthright citizens, depending on the law at time of birth, but are not qualified for the presidency.