However, I think the contention seems to be about McCain's UNIQUE circumstances in terms of YEAR and EXACT LOCATION of his birth.
McCains mother could have, as many Americans did, delivered in Colon Hospital in Colon, a facility built, owned, and located in a town owned by the Panama Railroad, a U.S. company, but under Panamanian sovereignty. He would have been a citizen at birth under R.S. § 1993, because born out of both the territory and jurisdiction of the United States.I have NO doubt that had McCain WON, the Left would be challenging him as many Conservatives are challenging Obama, based upon the arguments in this academic paper and in other investigations on this subject.
Under a principle called the "plenary power doctrine," judicial challenges to immigration and citizenship policies are strictly limited. The reverse of strict scrutiny, plenary power review is deferential in theory, virtually non-existent in fact. To this day, no person denied immigration or citizenship based on race, political belief, sex and out-of-wedlock birth or sexual orientation has persuaded the Supreme Court that such discrimination is unconstitutional. Because exclusion of undesirables might well be "essential . . . . to the preservation of our civilization," the Court holds that " 'over no conceivable subject is the legislative power of Congress more complete than it is over' the admission of aliens" and that it is unobjectionable that "in the exercise of its broad power over immigration and naturalization, "Congress regularly makes rules that would be unacceptable if applied to citizens.
Other foreign-born children of U.S. citizens were made U.S. citizens, as Senator McCain would have been had his mother elected to deliver a hundred yards over the border in the Republic of Panama. Birth in the Canal Zone is justifiably treated differently from birth in other parts of the world, but those differences warrant more favorable treatment, not less, as Congress determined in the 1937 Act. Arguably, a well-functioning Congress would not have left those born in the Canal Zone in limbo for years after the problem became clear in 1932.
Before hoosiermama jumps all over me, keep in mind I can’t be presisdent of the U.S. because I was born in the Canal Zone.
End of story.
Beit al-Ajaib - The House of Wonders Museum
In the House of Wonders Museum of History & Culture of Zanzibar & the Swahili Coast, the approach is deliberately historical, and it is intended to cover not only Zanzibar but also the whole Swahili coast from southern Somalia to northern Mozambique, because that is the cultural region.