[MadIvan]

If you really think that Rudy would make worse or equivalent appointments to the Supreme Court than Hillary or Obama, then you have problems.

Ivan

[Reagan Man]

If you think Rudy isn't a liberal and voting for him in the GOP primary would somehow solve all the problems facing America today, its you who has the problem.

Look Ivan. We go way back to another political website. I've always respected your opinion. On this one, you're deadwrong. All we have to go by in choosing a candidate are his/her governing record, political record and stated or written opinion. When I look at Rudy Giuliani, I see one thing, a liberal. I know all about the good job he did reducing crime in NYC. That is not enough to elect Rudy as the GOP nominee.

Besides, for the last five years Rudy has done NOTHING in any way about altering his political positions. I really believe Rudy would be more satisfied with a Lawrence Tribe, a George Mitchell or even an Alan Dershowitz on the SCOTUS, then a Constitutional conservative like J. Scalia, J. Thomas or CJ Rehnquist.

I see no good reason to vote for Rudy.