But if we are wrong, so what? If you are wrong...well, time will tell.
One of these days I'm going to run into a creationist that does not have an either-or mentality, but it has been eight years on these threads and so far I'm batting zero.
Perhaps God expects us to use the faculties for rational thought that he gave us, and punishes those who hold beliefs not supported by evidence. This may be unlikely, but can you really afford to take that chance?
You're unfamiliar with Islam?