[OldFriend]

Kelly Pickler was a lot more honest with herself. She knew when she didn't do right with a song. Whereas Kat complained that the judges were so hard on her.

It was never Kat's fault if the song didn't go well.

I'll take Pickler with her honesty any day.

[misterrob]

I was offering no opinion on her rather Simon thought that both she and Ace were something special and they turned out not to be in the eyes of the fans.

[Wyatt's Torch]

I'll take Pickler with her honesty any day.

I never thought I would say anything nice about her but I agree. I still think her Calamari and saLmon was an act but she was pretty real after singing. Like you, I'll take that any day.