You claimed WRT my post:
"pigdog post 310: "Nonsense, Finial. You've had it pointed out several times that the prebate is not a "guarantee" of anything, but is a refund of part of the taxes you'll have paid. Just like your April 15 tax refund presently." "
your response:
"A person/family qualifies for a prebate by being a citizen and applying. To say that it is a refund for taxes you'll have to pay is a lie. You get it no matter if you pay taxes or not. "
First of all, the qualification for the prebate is not being a citizen and applying but being a lawful resident and having a valid SSN. And it's no lie that it's a refund of taxes - that's where the money comes from; taxes. I doubt that there will be a single person who "pays no taxes" but you're welcome to think that if it pleases you.
Next, we see:
"pigdog post 317: Almost entirely rong Rightie. Savings are not taxed by the FairTax - consumption spending (or some part of it since not everything is taxed) is taxed. Savings & any earnings thereof remain untaxed. At present, whenever you buy something using tax or untaxed savings you still get nicked with the taxes embedded in prices since there's no free lunch, poddner!"
followed by:
"pigdog making false claims. No where did I ever say savings are taxed by the FairTax."
... nor did I claim that you said such a thing, but I don't hesitate to point out that in your post #69 which is the subject of this bit of insight, you said:
"... no savings are not taxed, earning on savings are taxed .... "
... and you show no gratitude for my correcting your foolish error shown in the two bolded portions just above - tsk, tsk!.
By that asnine logic, a welfare queen's welfare check is a 'refund' since it came from my taxes. You are a piece of work pigdog. Clinton had more shame than you. A person does not have to pay a dime of taxes to qualify for your precious pre-bate check. Only pigdog could convolute that into being a refund.
pigdog post 317: Almost entirely rong Rightie. Savings are not taxed by the FairTax
Always Right post 456: "pigdog making false claims. No where did I ever say savings are taxed by the FairTax."
pigdog post 487: "... nor did I claim that you said such a thing, but I don't hesitate to point out that in your post #69 which is the subject of this bit of insight, you said: "
Who was that in post 317???? Did someone rob your screen name and accuse me of being wrong about savings not being taxes by the fairtax???? You then continue you lying ways by taking a quote about I made about the income tax and falsely quote it as if I was talking about the fairtax. You lie, lie some more, then lie some more to cover it up.