I'm not a creationist, but I have NO sympathy for the darwinists.
But you give yourself away. You call your opponents "Materialist darwinists," and there is only one group who does that. See the The Wedge Strategy for more details.
And let me guess, your "honest and fair-minded critics of evolution theory" is based on the bible?
Am I close?
Do you also believe in a young earth and a global flood?
Waiting......
Waiting......
didn't think so
That being said, my friend my basis on the Bible, is used solely to explain for me what Science has failed to do.
And to answer your the question posed to JC, I do believe in young earth, as well as a global flood, and would love to hear your problem with these concepts.
So what how would you describe them?