Who cares? Evolution isn't atheistic. :)
Bollocks.
Evolutionism makes a Lie of the Explicit Statements of Jesus Christ regarding the Creation of the World. Jesus Christ claims in Mark 10:6 that God created Mankind as Male and Female "from the beginning of the creation".
You can believe in Jesus Christ, or you can believe in Evolutionism -- but considering that Jesus Christ claimed to be 100% Correct, one cannot believe in both.
And since Jesus is the One True God, Evolutionism is His Enemy.
So, yes... I suppose that an Evolutionist could still believe in some "Aristotelian First-Cause Demi-Urge" in order to get Life started (one would almost have to; Chemical Abiogenesis has been Scientifically Proven to be a Dead End; and even if it weren't, the odds of assembling a Self-Replicating Suite of left-handed proteins by mere chance are far beyond astronomical), and to keep Life going throughout the myriad of outright-miraculous biological advances needed in order to sustain the "evolution" of even one multi-cellular species in a trillion years; but if one is going to believe in the Real God of the Bible, then there is no space for detente.
One either believes in the Expressly-Creationistic claims of Jesus Christ of Nazareth, or one doesn't.
And if one does not believe in the Expressly-Creationistic claims of Jesus Christ of Nazareth, then one might as well be termed an "Atheist".
There's only One God, His name is Jesus, and if you deny His teaching on Creation -- then, yes, you're a "God-Denier"; and therefore, for all practical purposes, an Atheist.
Best, OP