[Right Wing Professor]

Have you stopped beating your wife?

If I were arguing against someone who said one shouldn't beat one's wife, that would be a good question.

I should have expected that yours was a purely negative contribution. Never mind.

[AndrewC]

Ah, you have troubles with analogy. In any case, you posted to me and my answer was effectively, "When have I ever said that the second law is violated?" I also point out that the mere presence of usable energy does not suffice.