To: Piers-the-Ploughman
Fellay labelling the mass evil (that's debatable?) is only one of many heresies he must repent of.
To: bornacatholic
"the New Mass is intrinsically evil" argument ---doesn't it run like this, at least I believe I have seen it on FR:
"St Thomas Aquinas says the privation of good is evil, ergo, since the New Mass has in some areas simplified or uses less precise language, it is evil because it has less good than TLM"
To be charitable, this is an academic argument that is overstated. There have to be better ways to argue the need for the TLM.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson