[gbcdoj]

Cardinal Ratizinger (Benedict XVI) was the one who said Dignitatis Humanae contradicted Quntra Cura.

Quote, please?

[sempertrad]

Cardinal Ratizinger (Benedict XVI) was the one who said Dignitatis Humanae contradicted Quntra Cura.

I have a quote from Yves Congar (not Ratzinger)"It cannot be denied that the affirmation of religious liberty by Vatican II says materially something other than what the Syllabus of 1864 said, and even just about the opposite of propositions 16, 17 and 19 of this document."

This quote was cited in "The Devil's Final Battle" by Fr. Paul Kramer and the footnote gives "Yves Congar, La Crise d'Eglise et Msgr. Lefebvre, (Paris, Cer, 1977) p. 54." as the source of the quote.

Hapax, could you be confusing this with then Cdl. Ratzinger's comment that Gaudium et Spes "is a revision of the Syllabus of Pius IX, a kind of countersyllabus..."?

Just putting it up here for your discussion.