JVDS hooks up with these girls for sex - He starts drugging them as most of them are not willing to go all the way with him. The Kalpoe brothers (and who knows who else) decided that they are going to drug a girl so that they can all have their way with her. Someone in the group decides to film it. So now there is a tape of some young girl being drugged and gag-raped by these 3 boys.
Joran decides to show this tape to one of the people who owns a casino. Maybe Joran is friends with this casino owner and knows that casino owner likes homemade porn and young girls. Joran strikes up a deal with the casino owner - Joran gets an open line of credit at the casino in which Joran does not have to pay back as long as Joran and his friends keeps making these little homemade porn movies. Everytime Joran comes up with a new homemade porn movie he gets XXXX amount of dollars added to his casino credit line.
Maybe other higher ups on the island also have taken a liking to Joran's little homemade porno movies. Many higher ups on the island have copies of Joran's little porn movie and there was plenty of them being made and Joran is getting his pockets lined with money from several higher up sources.
The girls (victims) are terrified to come forward since these little homemade movies are being made and paid for by many higher ups on the island.
Then comes Natalee - Joran decides they will drug and gang rape this pretty blond American girl and film it (premeditation) - something went wrong and Natalee fought back and one are all 3 of them killed her. Now they need to cover up the crime - a few calls and everything is taken care of - no body no crime. The problem is they had no idea that Natalee's mother would show up on the island and would refuse to leave the island until she had answers - then came the American media. (you all know the rest of the story).
If Joran or the other boys talk - then many people on the island will be exposed for them liking and buying (lining Joran's pockets with money and open credit lines) these little homemade porn movie that Joran has been making for some time now. Maybe the girls that have come forward now knowing that this story is not going away and that it has enough world media attention that they feel safe enough to come forward now.
FBI and most likely Natalee's parents have known about the little homemade movies pretty early on but they had to find out who the other victims were so that they could get them to talk. It is possible that ALE now has at least one of these little home made porn movies of Joran's. - Joran's father may be involved with it also as he also may have a taste for homemade porn even if his son is in it. The homemade movies could be taken or edited enough not show any faces in them.
Just another theory based on things I read about some of the people who live on the island. Someone had to supply Joran with the ruffies - someone was playing Joran for these homemade porn movies - someone may have disposed of Natalee's body to help Joran out because they also did not want to be found out about.
Does Aruba want their dirty little pervert secret out so that whole world can hear and learn about it? - Aruba will not be able to keep it quiet if these girls gain the courage to speak up about what has been happening to them on the island.
Sounds plausible
I'd be looking for people/person within their circle who has a professional video type studio or equipment. Could be that they just (secretly) down load these XXX movies on the internet and charge people to see these vile images providing a world of income for the group to split.
Thousands of girls could have been victims of these guys.
All along I have thought that Joran was more likely to be indebted to someone rather than running any kind of "business" operation. He may have thought himself a big-shot but when you're talking about the porn industry, money laundering, drug trafficking, etc. I highly doubt that a 17 year old kid is going to get anything except what he's allowed by that underworld (and teenagers don't exactly have that right resume).
I would think Joran would be quite a hire for an underworld enterprise. He has the looks to lure and a connected father to blackmail.
I hate to think of it, but the movie 8MM keeps popping in my head.