VAN SUSTEREN: During the time that you were talking to Beth at the gas station, did the discussion of that phone call come up again?
C. CROES: Yes, it did.
VAN SUSTEREN: After you and Beth listened to that phone call several times and hung up with the person in the states, what did you do next?
C. CROES: After that, we spoke a while. And then we left that location with the intention of going to the Holiday Inn to continue meeting. On the way there, a young man and I were sitting in my car. And on the way there, instinctively, I wanted to go to drive off, pull over to the cabana area, just to look to see if perhaps she was there.
Then Croes decides to stop at the cabana? Whatever call he listened to apparently didn't rule out that Natalee was both alive and on the island at that point.
IMO, that was a bizarre interview; he acted like a psyhic, with all that "I just felt like going here......and then here."