[Doctor Stochastic]

Intelligence implies a designer.

Then you would not object to a teacher pointing out what a poor job of design it was.

[MacDorcha]

Then you would not object to a teacher pointing out what a poor job of design it was.

ok then wise-guy. you make a better one.

[Sola Veritas]

I wrote - "Intelligence implies a designer."

You responded:
"Then you would not object to a teacher pointing out what a poor job of design it was."

Certainly not, if that teacher can show the correct DNA code of amino acid sequences to correct the proteins that caused this "poor" design. I doubt that many, if any, could do this.

[bondserv]

Then you would not object to a teacher pointing out what a poor job of design it was.

I believe the Bible indicates that a curse has tainted, and continues to taint the Creation. We would need the original design to make your assessment. The presumptuous teacher commits the ASSUME mistake in your scenario.