Replies

Well, I can't speak for ALL Constitutional Republics, but a perfect example would be how we elect a president. Sure, everyone votes, however in this country we don't vote directly for President - it's not a case of "The one with the majority of the votes wins", but we go through the "Electoral College" instead - for the very reason that the smaller states would be subject to the "tyranny of the larger states" if we didn't.

If we were a pure democracy, we'd state our preference for president and the most votes would win. That is simply not the case in our republic.

Am I making sense, or are people still confused?

I'm not confused, Chad. Your ideas make perfect sense, and I wholeheartedly agree with your take on the subject.

Now, excuse me while I go find a hankie to wipe off my nose.

Well, I can't speak for ALL Constitutional Republics, but a perfect example would be how we elect a president. Sure, everyone votes, however in this country we don't vote directly for President

That's an interesting point. However, I don't think getting rid of the electoral college would make our government a democracy, rather than a republic. For example, France bills itself a republic, but they elect their president directly. On the other hand, the UK doesn't elect their Prime Minister directly- he is chosen by his party and the Prime Minister can actually change without any involvement of the electorate (such as the case where Margaret Thatcher stepped down in the midde of a term and was replaced by John Major), but the UK is not technically a republic.

Maybe we're just arguing definitions here. As a quick guide, Black's law dictionary defines a Democracy as:

That form of government in which the sovereign power resides in and is exercised by the whole body of free citizens directly or indirectly through a system of representation.

A Republican form of government is defined as:

A government by representatives chosen by the people.

It would seem that the US falls under both definitions.