Long Island pizzeria goes viral for Thanksgiving pie with all the trimmings: ‘Probably sold over 500 pies’

NY Post ^ | 11/22/2025 | Angela Barbuti

[DFG]

[Liz]

The Gobbler.

[ridesthemiles]

LOOKS DELICIOUS

[moviefan8]

I would love to try this pie, but the pizzeria is too far from me.

[Highest Authority]

DISGUSTING!!!
Where I come from, makin’ that pie would be a hangin’ offense!

[UnwashedPeasant]

Looks delicious, except for the cranberry sauce.

But that cranberry sauce helped them get viral free advertising.

[j.havenfarm]

I wouldn’t care for it. What makes it an atrocity is the cranberry sauce. Sweet and savory don’t go together on pizza. The diseased mindset to the contrary is what gave us pineapple on pizza

[Dr. Sivana]

Where I come from, makin’ that pie would be a hangin’ offense!

Heck, it should be a hanging offense where he is. They have plenty of good pizza in Long Island.

[Libloather]

Drive a long way? You gotta smell it the whole way back.

[gloryblaze]

Looks delicious, except for the cranberry sauce....

Best served on the side, cold, IMHO.

[sonova]

I would not call that pizza. Maybe tastes good, but pizza? Nope.

[GenXPolymath]

tecnicamente sarebbe una torta di carne

[GenXPolymath]

Looks good, I have a wood fired pizza oven in the outside kitchen I see where some of the left overs are going to be fired up on a imported OO Napoletana Tipo 48 hour proofed crust. And yeah cranberry whole not jelly we are not savages on the side should someone want to dip in.

[null and void]

Yes, it needs cheese...

[TalBlack]

When I lived in Deer Park many moons ago I called it little Brooklyn. There was a pizza joint every fifteen feet. Any Italian bread or specialty you could get in Brooklyn you could get in Deer Park. As late as four years ago driving along 231 I saw yet another new pizza joint grand opening. As expected it was amazing. Ya have to be therabouts to survive.

[Dacula]

Put pineapple on and watch people go ballistic.

[Secret Agent Man]

Sorry, what they did to that makes it no longer a pizza.

[Rural_Michigan]

Needs mashed potatoes. Looks good to me I don’t care what you call it

[Orosius]

“I don’t want it around schools, I don’t want it sold to children. But putting cranberries on pizza? That’s an infamia.”

[1FreeAmerican]

There is a small grocery store/sandwich shop in Makawao (Maui) that makes turkey dinner sandwich’s every day. Turkey, gravy, stuffing, and sliced cranberry (from the can).

You’d better be there before 11am or “your not getting one bradda”!