Posted on 02/15/2007 4:07:26 PM PST by CDB
This is the film where Clint Eastwood wants to portray the Japanese soldier as being, just like the rest of us: Sensitive, caring and concerned for our fellow man. Dont you believe it!
Japanese soldiers, who were medical officers, carried out biological experiments on prisoners of war. The opening scene in "The Great Raid" movie showing Japanese soldiers burning American POWs alive is not fiction. It is reality.
The record of the atrocities inflicted by the Japanese soldiers on the American and Filipino civilians is numbered in the thousands. In Manila alone, as the war was winding down and the Japanese knew the end was near, they slaughtered more than 100,000 men, women and children.
The brilliant book "The Rape of Nanking" written by the late Iris Chang, chronicles the appalling savagery of the Japanese army during the 1930s. Ms. Chang uncovered the history of more than 360,000 Chinese men, women and children who were massacred by Japanese soldiers; some were, no doubt, the same nice guys on Iwo Jima.
It was the Japanese who attacked the United States: It was the Japanese soldier who savagely killed thousands of unarmed POWs, It was the Japanese soldier who placed POWs into bomb shelters and set them on fire so that no one could escape: and it was the Japanese soldiers who refused the offer of surrender when made, while knowing that to continue fighting meant death to hundreds of thousands of their own people,
I think it is safe to say that Mr. Eastwood will not be getting any of our money.
My dad was a WW II vet who had a close friend who was also a Bataan Death March Survivor. He was missing three fingers on one hand. My dad told me the Japanese had cut off one finger at a time with an ax because he had cut wood too long for the wood stoves. "Flags of Our Fathers" did not depict the barbarism of the Japanese that was shown in the book either.
Thanks. As good as this movie looks (they had a Hollywood vs history thing on the history channel and the movie replicated historical film and photos in many places) - I've heard enough about it to know that I won't be spending my money to hear how the Japs were "just like our guys".
My thanks to Dr. Tenny for his service to our country.
I loved the Great Raid movie...can't say the same about much else out of Hollywood.
nor mine
Did you see the film? That's a complete misrepresentation of its content.
Mr. Eastwood is a liar.
I am very disappointed in him.
Amen and thank you for recounting the truth of that horrific event in American history that Hollywood purposefully fails to tell. We owe it to those who did not survive that brutal time in history and those who are no longer here to tell their story.
Good points. I would like to see a current movie depicting the evils of the Japanese atrocities. However, as the writer admits, the soldiers at Iwo Jima may have been quite different. This seems especially plausible since we're talking, essentially, about the end of the war. Perspectives may well have changed and "humanized." It's also possible that the available human material in the later stages of the war for losing armies -- Japanese and German -- was younger and/or gentler, losing armies have to reach further and further into the available pool to keep up their manpower.
It was an excellent movie and could have been much more relativistic than it was. It could also have been anti-American, and wasn't. I don't think it conveyed a message about the pointlessness of the war from an American standpoint, but rather conveyed the increasing pointlessness of Japanese resistance, and the human side of the Japanese soldiers.
It would be interesting to hear from someone who actually knows what the Japanese on Iwo Jim were like.
Thank you for your service to our country, Dr. Tenney and thank you for this review. That's a movie I will not see.
The Japanese were not portrayed as saints. And the Americans weren't portrayed as phonies -- they were barely portrayed at all. And I don't believe the Americans actually were saints, either. How could they have been?
thanks for posting
The Great Raid movie was indeed a well done film, in my opinion.
The scene where the Battalion Commander is workin' over the Japs in a stream with his Springfield is absolutely wonderful!
Semper Fi,
"This is the film where Clint Eastwood wants to portray the Japanese soldier as being, just like the rest of us: Sensitive, caring and concerned for our fellow man. Dont you believe it!"
I don't. They were MONSTERS!
Using bayonets to pierce babies thrown up in the air - it's ALL TRUE. They remind me of Muslim terrorists - little difference.
I saw the movie and I liked it. I didn't accept the premise that the enemy was just like us.
ping
I saw "Letters..." I thought it was a very good movie. I didn't think that it sanitized the Japanese. It showed a couple of Japanese who were scared young men filled with doubt, and most of the Japanese were simply doing whatever they could to fight and die "honorably". But it did not draw any equivalence between American and Japanese societies of the time, or between the overall conduct of our respective militaries. It just showed the experiences of a handful of soldiers in one particular (losing) battle.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.