American Idol 2006--Live Thread (Part III)

Fox ^ | 5-8-06

[silent_jonny]

always for Tammy

[new cruelty]

Yep. Chris is just a cool dude. Fun to watch and root for. The remaining three don't hold my interest, though I wish them well.

[Netizen]

Goodnight, hopefully you will be all better and refreshed by next week.

[silent_jonny]

I think this is the most shocking thing I've ever seen on American Idol

I think so too. It even dwarfs the Tamyra Gray elimination in the first season.

[Carolinamom]

Speaking of shocks, has the thought that KM just might become AI ever entered anyone's mind?

[Feiny]

AI will no longer have me as a viewer. I wanted a Taylor-Chris final 2. I am so glad I know the results now so I don't give them any ratings tonight. AI is now banned forever in my home.

[silent_jonny]

This sure took the wind out of my AI sails. :(

Same here :-/

[Senator Goldwater]

"You sure are one ugly person!"

Don't hate me because I have hair.

[Apple Blossom]

I agree. No one is more surprised than Kat that she is coming back next week.

Two things to consider:
1)Kat and Elliott probably got most of the votes from Paris' fans.
2)Who is most likely to get Chris' votes next week?

That should keep us busy 'til next Teusday....

[Conservative Texan Mom]

I don't care to watch anymore either. He was the only one I enjoyed. Okay, yes he's hot, but he's also got a great voice.

Taylor has a good voice, but people complain when he doesn't dance. That leads me to believe that many enjoy watching him more than listening to him. It's a singing competition,

Also, I get the same feeling I had with Rueben and Fantasia. Not personally about Taylor, he seems like a nice guy, and will have a great career. I'm referring to the band wagon thing. Rueben and Fantasia both won because they were promoted as different and exciting. People started piling on because it was the popular thing to do. Taylor is in a way different league than those two, but I think some of this is still going on.

[OldFriend]

This old broad is doing the happy dance tonight.

I've come to really enjoy watching Taylor.

He seems to have music in his very soul.

[andyssister]

I just want to say that over the past few weeks I've read posts discussing Katherines

"boobs

"McTa-Tas"

and the "junk in her trunk".

Tonight alone, "tits" has been used a number of times. How incredibly juvenile. And it's no less offensive than people making fun of Elliott's teeth.

[Jrabbit]

wrong....not sulking....I never could get through to vote anyway. If I try again, I'll vote for Taylor.

[RobFromGa]

Chris ain't going nowhere. Women love Chris and women vote.

You were saying?

[Samwise]

Wohoo!

Glad to see my dialing counted. I was, however, shocked to see Chris go. I do like him when he sings, just not when he screams. Katherine is lucky. Taylor still befuddles me.

[buckeyesrule]

Fox News and CNN are reporting that women all over America have been slashing their wrist's because they are so sad that Chris was eliminated.

[silent_jonny]

Thanks for the spoiler.

You're welcome. I'm sorry I didn't spoil you with better news.

[del4hope]

Maybe it was the behind the scenes "shadow" judges? You know the ones who count their $$$$.

[Conservative Texan Mom]

I thought the Pickle was adorable, but I never thought she should make it past #6, which is where she went out.

Yes, to each his/her own.
Elliot is a nice guy, and a boring performer.

[RobFromGa]

Now you've got your chance to give Chris a shoulder to cry on...

[Senator Goldwater]

"Fox News and CNN are reporting that women all over America have been slashing their wrist's because they are so sad that Chris was eliminated"

They should show their solidarity tomorrow and shave their heads, like the Manson women.