American Idol 2006--Live Thread (Part III)

Fox ^ | 5-8-06

[Apple Blossom]

She is on fire but the background music is toooooo loud.

The band was too loud for everyone, especially Elliott! What were they trying to do, cover up his great vocals?

[Hildy]

Thank you. You have a firm grasp on the obvious.

[silent_jonny]

Kat has a terrific voice. It is better then Elliot and I hate to say it better than Taylors

No way.

[Senator Goldwater]

"Have yet to get through for Chris"

That's because his first caller is still talking to him.

[I'm ALL Right!]

eh? My 35 year old fogie ears didn't hear you....

[Conservative Texan Mom]

I imagine that those two appeal more to the younger crowd.

[retrokitten]

LOL!!!

[TonyWpi]

"Kat has a terrific voice. It is better then Elliot and I hate to say it better than Taylors"

I used to think so too, but I must have been drooling too loud and missed some of the bad notes!

But in truth, Katharine does sing well...but we're at the point where you've got to be at your best ALL the time and tonight she fell flat. (vocally that is)

[Conservative Texan Mom]

You are indeed correct. It was the previous week that they were off.

[EmilyGeiger]

Hey! I am so sick, I set my VCR to tape the show and when I left the room evidently my daughter changed it to tape the Disney channel! We got home and it was 2 hrs. of that's so RAven!! I missed the show and House. Would any kind soul tell me what happened and where I can hear the songs?

[silent_jonny]

Simon got the Kat Death Stare.

That even scares me a little :o

[I'm ALL Right!]

You're cracking me up.

[Alissa]

My order tonight was Chris & Elliott a tie
Kat - because she was the most challenged with Elvis
Taylor - last in my opinion, especially when he should have shined

[retrokitten]

LA Woman3 posted this link earlier:

http://www.idol-thoughts.com/My_Homepage_Files/Page42.html

[I'm ALL Right!]

You can hear the performances at idolthoughts.com

[RobFromGa]

THey were right the week before too.

DialIdol
Rank

Idol

DialIdol Score

Margin Of Error

Actual Rank

1-3

Taylor Hicks

26.01

1.581

-

1-3

Chris Daughtry

25.954

1.582

-

1-4

(B3)

Elliott Yamin

23.721

1.605

-

3-5

(B3)

Katharine McPhee

22.467

1.619

-

4-6

(B3)

Kellie Pickler

19.421

1.65

6

5-6

(B3)

Paris Bennett

17.36

1.671

5

[Apple Blossom]

Chris is the best screamer. Kat can actually sing. I thought her first song was great and I loved seeing her move around the stage. Problem is
1) she forgot lyrics (we don't forgive THAT easily)
2) was out of breath for the last note

I think what Tommy said was right, she sings better than we have seen on the show, her second song wasn't that great.

Remember, Kat and Elliott are probably splitting votes that used to go to Paris.

[retrokitten]

I'm a little afraid to try it though, because we live fairly close to Midway Airport. Last thing I need to do is accidentally direct a Southwest jet to land on the lawn.

[silent_jonny]

Good night, TOL :)

[I'm ALL Right!]

Thanks again, SJ!