The first time it happened would have been the last and my lawyer would have seen to that.
As freeper E. Pluribus Unum posted: “They arrested her for the same car rental multiple times.”
This has been going on for some time now. Years and years of it. People will rent a car, go on vacation with the car, and suddenly find themselves under arrest for car theft. That’s even though they have a receipt showing they have paid for the car rental. Also Hertz will report a car stolen even though it was returned on time. I’ve been reading these types articles for years. Don’t rent from Hertz!