Good post.
One of the explanations also could be something about the nature of time. There could hypothetically be extremely rare weird things like rogue waves of the ocean, but that happen with time. Perhaps they are influenced by something to do with humans and their experiences, like strong emotion that occurs in death or stress.
That also doesn’t mean that there aren’t real instances of what is thought of as ‘supernatural phenomena.’ Personally I believe in miracles allowed and willed by God, and the actions of malevolent entities, demons.
But I have never experienced anything that I categorize as supernatural. Deja vu has happened many times, also probably unspecific weird coincidences, but nothing I have ever thought was important enough to remember.
Freegards
I have had lots of dreams with minor things in them that make me notice the next day. Two of which were much more detailed and came true.
But probably once a week something stupid. The other night I had a dream of riding a bike and parking it but not having a lock to lock it up with. (I don’t ride a bike).
The next day I was in a classroom (first time in a year) with my daughter. Wrapped around the leg of a desk was a bike lock and cable. Goofy. I wonder if we don’t dream about thousands of things in a night, and then we see something that reminds us. But that happens to me often.
Doesn’t explain the detailed foretelling dreams.
I was telling my older brother about a re-occuring dream I had as a child, with the stairs flattening out and me falling back into the basement (where the monsters were). “Wow! My reoccuring nightmare was trying to climb a sand dune and always sliding down!” Weird!” He’s 14 years older than me.
I knew a guy that was a Christian and in the DIA. He had all sorts of crazy stories with the supernatural. I believed him too (still do!)