You look again. There are many different door configurations for the Cessna Caravan, which is smaller than the plane, a Cessna Caravan Grand, that Fuddy and Puente were passengers on.
Most of all, the ID numbers on the tails are different.
Are they really???
Take a close look at the last two letters on the side of the tail section -- the M and the A -- and tell me if you don't see the faint outline of those two letters there in the other picture as well.
Try the pictures at post #21
The M and the A are there -- not clearly -- but they are there.
Is it confirmed that the numbers on both planes are different? Can we put them side by side in one photo and show what is what?