geez, that is about as rational as saying that the child that converts to Christianity from any other faith of their parents, could not be a good christian or a minister, eventually raising up to head the national organization of say, Baptists or Catholics.
Are you arguing that our Founders were irrational or that "natural born citizen" means something else?
Do you agree that the Founders intended to remove some citizens from consideration for the highest office?
If so, why do you think that was?
Both of my grandsons were born to a foreign national, only one of them in the U.S. Do I think they might grow up to have divided loyalties? Of course I do. They are being raised in a household by a foreigner with beliefs, customs, family, and loyalties associated with their father's country of birth.
Gee, poor me, the Founders cheated me out of having a grandson in the Whitehouse.