[bushpilot1]

You evaded my question...you wrote. “WKA was decided correctly”.

How was it decided correctly? Was it a correct decision giving citizenship to the children of aliens or an alien parent?

How is this a correct decision?

[Seizethecarp]

“Was it a correct decision giving citizenship to the children of aliens or an alien parent?”

I evaded nothing. I explained the ruling, IIUC, as interpreting the 14A to have made WKA a 14A citizen at birth, a new subclass of citizens at birth that needed clarification after the passage of the 14A. This is the subclass of citizens at birth, children of aliens and foreigners, about which the Minor court said there were doubts, but which could not reach to resolve at the time.

WKA was correct in resolving those doubts in favor of WKA being a 14A citizen at birth, IMO.

[El Gato]

Was it a correct decision giving citizenship to the children of aliens or an alien parent?

Yes, but not natural born citizenship.