Apparently Dr. Kullander doesn't see that natural ratio as evidence of a scam, or impossible.....just "weird"I wonder if anyone ever asked Dr. Kullander if the sample was consistent with someone just mixing together some naturally-occuring Copper and some naturally-occuring Iron with some naturally-occuring Nickel?
I wonder if anyone asked him if there is anything at all about the sample that would preclude such an occurrence?
People like Dr. Kullander are giving Rossi a professional courtesy he doesn't deserve. They are assuming that he behaving like a researcher, honestly reporting all the relevant data, when he clearly is not. You yourself admitted earlier in this thread that he was lying (although you gave him an undeserved courtesy of using the phrase "deliberate misdirection").
Science, and scientists are often the least capable of spotting fraud, because their entire process is build on the assumption that if it happens it will be detected when others attempt to replicate the experiment. Rossi is "cheating" that process, so he doesn't deserve any presumption of honesty normally accorded researchers.
New Warthog policy. I will not respond to any reply that contains anything about "it's a scam". None. Zero. I've had it with you jerks recirculating the same stale comments over and over stated a hundred different ways and/or sourced from different "skeptic" forums.
If you want to discuss the science, techniques or similar facets of either Rossi's rig or cold fusion, I'm your guy.
Otherwise, you're wasting your time (as I've decided to stop wasting mine in paying attention to you).