No, feelings have nothing to do with my POV. Three years of reading about the topic inform me.
A person can have NBC status at birth but renounce it. Obviously.
Sheesh, how stupid can you be.
But my applying for an Italian passport doesn't require me to renounce anything. You claim to have read about this subject for three years. Maybe you can point to the actual law that says that applying for a second passport as a dual citizen requires renunciation of natural born citizen status and what the actual process for that would be.