[Political Junkie Too]

Her citizenship was established by the circumstances of her birth, not the Constitution.

I was simply restating what I thought was the gist of the discussion in this thread. I was not debating the facts of the case.

But I appreciate the meaning of your statement.

-PJ

[SatinDoll]

Your understanding is just fine. Lawyers and fussy-sorts like pinpoint accuracy. For lay folks, it isn’t necessary. You have the ‘gist’.