“A reasonable man would expect them to be almost exactly alike.”
Subjective judgement.
They are almost exactly alike. The forms are the same, both show funny pencil marks for some reason.
But were they typed up by different people? Why would you expect everything to be the same if they were?
The documents are recording events one day apart.
They were created in the same place. It not be unreasonable to expect the same person to have typed them.
And as such, it would not be unreasonable to expect entries boxes 8,10,13, and 15 at the left margin, as in Nordyke. Likewise, boxes 9, 12b, and 14.
Seems reasonable to me, anyway.