[flushing_kenny]

Well, the WSJ didn’t like it, mostly because they didn’t understand this novel.
This is not a fun book, but it is about adulthood and of course, death.
The WSJ did not understood Kreacher and the attention devoted to him.
Thinking about, the other movies excluded Kreacher, even though he is used
To trach a valuable lesson “you sow what you reap”, along with “do unto
Others as you will others do to you”.
This a a final book to the saga and for at least the first movie,
there is little fun. It is about as fun as Vichy France.

I will pay my 2300 yen and see it within a week. :aving read the books, I
Am ready for Harry to grow up.

[MarkL]

Agreed. I wish they would have given Kreacher a bit more time in "Order of the Phoenix," especially his interactions with Serius, but I realize they were under time constraints. Still, I was really hoping that we'd get to see "Kreacher's Tale" in this movie.

Still, I think they did a remarkably good job on this movie. I just wish that they wouldn't have had the "dance" scene in the tent. It was unnecessary, not in the book, and actually took away from the deep sadness that Hermione had in the book.

Mark