[allmendream]

“To be a Constitutionally qualified ‘natural born citizen’, both parents must be natural born citizens, of the USA.” Tarpon Post #3.

Your made up definition. If not made up by you, made up by someone else. It obviously is not true, and it is ridiculous to suggest that it is.

According to the definition you supplied, if an immigrant became a U.S. citizen, married another U.S. citizen, then their offspring would NOT be natural born, as their immigrant parent was a “naturalized” not a “natural born” citizen.

Are you backing away from your made up definition? Repudiating it? Admitting that it is fiction?

[Tarpon]

Ah yes ... I think my error quoting the article that said both parents must be natural born was incorrect ... Yes, could be. That would make it a decreasing pool as you said of people, now that I re-read it. Sorry, my bad.

So you agree with the statement one born in the country, of parents who were citizens of that country. Is that better?