Replies

Taliban may have origin in ancient tribe of Israel-
Anthropologist finds many similarities

Frank Viviano, Chronicle Staff Writer

Saturday, October 20, 2001

http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2001/10/20/MN.DTL

(10-20) 04:00 PST Jerusalem — Preoccupied with their own terrorist war at home, Israelis have paid less attention than the rest of the world to the campaign against Afghanistan’s ruling Taliban.

Just as well, says an Israeli anthropologist — because the Taliban might have had Jewish origins.

According to Shalva Weil, there is considerable body of evidence suggesting that the Pathan ethnic group, from which most of the Taliban are drawn, is one of the fabled “10 lost tribes” of ancient Israel. Indeed, as recently as half a century ago, Pathan tribesmen themselves claimed that they were descended from wandering Jews.

Writing in the weekly magazine “Jerusalem Report,” Weil cites a report delivered to Israeli President Yitzhak Ben-Zvi in the 1950s, based on the encounter of a Jewish traveler with Pathan nomads.

The Pathans, who are also called Pashtuns, were said to wear cloaks decorated with a symbol that closely resembled the lamps lit by Jews at Hanukkah. The traveler also reported that they donned prayer shawls similar to those of their Jewish counterparts in the West, insisted that men grow side curls, and lit votive candles on Friday evenings, the beginning of the Jewish Sabbath.

Some anthropologists have also found Pathan families that circumcise sons on the eighth day after their birth, in keeping with Jewish custom.

A legend of the Pathans, as recounted to Weil when she did field research among them in the 1980s along the Pakistani border, tells of a “Jeremiah,” a son of King Saul — but not the more familiar Jeremiah of the Old Testament — who sired a daughter named “Afghana.” Her descendants, the legend maintains, made their way to the Central Asian land that now bears her name.

A Jewish connection of more recent and well-documented origin leads just across Afghanistan’s western frontier to the Iranian city of Mashhad. It is the traditional home of the “Mashhadi Jews,” who were forcibly converted to Shiite Islam after a pogrom in 1839.

Like some of their distant Sephardic cousins in Islamic Spain, the Mashhadi Jews behaved in public as faithful Muslims — even making the pilgrimage to Mecca when they could afford it — but clung secretly to Judaism at home.