Duh!
But they are both in Long Island, where you said Rudy is not from.
He grew up in GC. He and Judi have their “summer home” in the Hamptons.
If that’s the only part of my comment that bears even the slightest inaccuracy, then I stand vindicated. Besides, Long Islanders don’t really think of Garden City as part of LI, given that it is in Queens. Geographically LI, but not culturally.