Interesting theory. Especially since the very person involved told you differently, and the Chief of Police confirmed his version of events. Yet somehow you can sit in front of a keyboard and claim to know better than the people on the ground.
You remind me of the liberals who second guess our troops half a world away, because they feel the need to make events fit their predispositions.
Now what do you think he's going to say? Tell me you're not that naive.
"and the Chief of Police confirmed his version of events"
The Chief of Police asked the girlfriend. The girlfriend confirmed the version of events.
"Yet somehow you can sit in front of a keyboard and claim to know better than the people on the ground."
My theory makes 10X more sense than his "facts". Did you read that story of his?
"because they feel the need to make events fit their predispositions."
Occam's Razor, my friend.