So after running on and on about "logic logic logic", Dataman immediately goes to:
The lurkers are watching. So give it another try.
Matter: is it
eternal
or
created?
Someone who was actually as logical as he thought he was wouldn't stub his toe so badly on such a blatant "false dichotomy" fallacy...
It's only a false dichotomy if there is a third choice. What is the third choice? Matter was either created or it was not created.