Made up situations do not prove anything. There are also many people who will say they believe in evolution because they have never really looked at it. I think one of the basis of liberalism is moral relativism and this is very much a part of evolutionary theory. Ideas have consequences and the tendency of evolution is towards liberalism.
New Point #3: I've learned a lot since joining this thread, and the following statement derives from this attained knowledge. If a large number of RATIONAL men believe something to be true, it is irrational to conclude with complete authority that they are incorrect unless you can provide absolute and compelling evidence which destroys the theory. This is true for religion, and right now, it holds true for evolution.
The argument from authority does not work if those who claim authority do not have any rational refutation to the point being made.
The only thing made up there is the Starbucks. Insert Free Republic instead. The person is me.
Well maybe not 'prove' anything. But the use of parables can be a handy teaching tool. They can also be used to show another where he is at fault without obviously and personally attacking him or her. Somebody else did the same in history, can't think of the name, um... Can you help me?