Not a chance. That makes the individual a servant of the state, not the other way around. It means our rights are not inherent but are at the whim of the state. It is akin to how feudal systems operate.
.
Indeed, it is slavery.
It effectively begins to change the constitution to “You have these rights if....”.
I think I prefer my rights God given.
Earned Citizenship is the first step in creating a Meritocracy
IMHO - the Republic is Broken and must be Replaced
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meritocracy
It is a very durable form of Governance
Agreed.
As was said before,
Rights are inherent to all
They are not infringed
However...
If one does not Serve the Country,
The Country is not obligated to Serve back
The Obligating of Service is Mutual
This includes ALL the Social Supports
There is no Obligation to Serve the Country
You are Free to do what You Will
But the Social Services of the Government are for those Served
Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, Government Schools, etc.
Voting in an innate aspect of this
A Vote is a Command to the Government to do your Will
The Government is not Commanded
unless one has served Under Command
All rights but the vote would be inherent to non citizens